Standout BB10 + Z10 Thoughts

If you know me, it’s been obvious for years that I’m not a big fan of the former Research In Motion or their line of products. I don’t care for tactile keyboards. I’ve never liked the OS. More importantly though, I don’t care for phones that literally freeze up on their users. I would cringe when people would tell me troubleshooting steps included “pulling the battery.” When the stock tanked and the company looked on the brink of destruction over the last year and a half my only thought was “justice.” The light at the end of the dark tunnel was Blackberry 10 though. While I knew I wasn’t going to be jumping ship from Apple (another company that doesn’t realize how much some of its users HATE them right now) I was hopeful for Blackberry. I wanted them to put together a launch that blew my mind. After all, they’ve had A LONG TIME to prepare this launch and know it’s make or break. What I came away with was this
The Hub, Flow/Peek, and Keyboard are cool.
Everything else? Meh…
Let’s get the good out of the way first. The Hub is sheer genius in terms of managing all of your applications on the fly. The UI is by far the most slick of all mobile Operating Systems currently on the market. It manages everything seamlessly. As Microsoft is so ardently trying to point out in their 1 billion dollar (*shudder*) ad campaign, it’s all about getting in and out of your phone as quickly as possible. The Hub not only does that, it’s done in a far less clunky manner than Windows 8, iOS and Android. Similarly, Peek/Flow work within the Hub so you can see what’s going on at any given point without having to open/close everything. Right now, users have grown used to opening an app and part closing to get to another app. There are obvious exceptions like how the Samsung Galaxy S 3 and Note II handle multitasking. However, for the most part it’s an “in & out” experience. Peek/Flow combined with Hub blew my mind in terms of handling everything on the fly. For people that are truly gogogo, they’ll jump at the opportunity to use this software. Good on Blackberry for taking the time to create a truly innovative experience. As far as the OS goes, I consider BB10 a step above any current mobile OS on the market.
To say I was impressed with the touchscreen keyboard would be an engrossing understatement. It looks to be fantastic in terms of predicting which words the user would like to use and also incorporating the ability to flick up the full predicted word without creating a cumbersome experience. That’s no small feat. Blackberry’s competitors will need to step up their keyboard game. The iOS keyboard is a joke. The stock Android keyboard is even worse. I’m a big fan of Swipe for Android but from the look of things, Blackberry 10′s native keyboard stomps on it with ease. I would figure developers in the Big 2 will be looking for a way to steal (or as Apple would say “innovate”) the keyboard functionality ASAP as it has clearly set a new standard.
That’s the end of my praise.
Let’s touch on the rest shall we?
GUTS
4.2 inch LCD with a 1280 x 768 resolution and 356 Pixels Per Inch
Dual Core 1.5ghz processor
2GB RAM
8MP 1080p Back Facing Camera. 2MP 720p Front Facing Camera.
1800amh battery
I don’t care about whatever “ometer” twisty turny compass BS that gets thrown in SmartPhones nowadays so I’m not listing them. I just want to hit on the stuff that the average person would care about (aka is it fast?). Personally, I think the size of the display is perfect. I’ve always wanted one thing from a Smartphone; an HD display in as small a size as possible. The display and size of the phone is EXACTLY what I was hoping the iPhone 5 would be last fall. It should be noted that at 356 PPI, the Z10 is actually BETTER than Apple’s much ballyhoo’d Retina Display (326 PPI). The processor, RAM and Camera are nothing to write home about. It puts the Z10 on par with the high end phones that dropped last year. Sadly, that hardware will also be outdated by the time the Galazy S4 and iPhone 5S drop in the summer. I was shocked to see how small the battery was. Considering the amount of work that BB10 is going to have to do on a sustained basis, I can’t imagine that battery putting up nearly the kind of life the average “power user” is going to need. I anticipate a lot of “OMG MY BB DIES AFTER LIKE… 20 MINUTES (20 minutes being around 6 hours).
So in the end, Blackberry did something very right in their software and powered it with average hardware. I absolutely love BB10! It’s slick, smooth and brings a lot to the table that iOS and Android simply don’t have. The Z10 hardware on the other hand leaves the standard “Blackberry is still playing catch up” argument out there. For me the question always comes down to “should I buy it?” For all of the current Blackberry users who have been hoping for the Messiah, I wouldn’t argue against a purchase. It’s leaps and bounds above any model currently on the market under Blackberry/RIM. As for current iOS users on a 4S or 5 or Android users on a device released in the last 12 months? I can’t fathom dropping money to jump ship. The software will eventually be bastardized and replicated on iOS and Android respectively. The hardware would make for a lateral move if you have a decent phone.
BB users have fun with your new toy. Everyone else, there’s better ways to blow your money.
NOTE: this is not meant as a comprehensive review. There are Godlike sites like Mobilesyrup for that. I’m just a phone nerd dropping thoughts on yet another phone in a saturated market and what aspects of it actually caught my eye one way or another.
Questions/comments/constructive criticism is welcome.



Hey Justin,
Thanks for a great post!
I can totally appreciate this review. I know that I probably won’t be rushing to purchase one, I’m glad to see they’ve made some improvements regarding the OS and are really working at recapturing their market. Well done. Good luck BB!
Love when you do tech reviews… We generally agree
Certainly a nice first impressions review. Felt a lot of the same things!
I feel like both models were designed to KEEP their current customers who may have been on the fence and contemplating leaving. The NEXT thing they bring out might be enough to pull people back.
I’m split on that one. I think the Q10 was meant to retain their current users. They just HAD TO HAVE a tactile keyboard or the world would end. The Z10 I firmly believe was/is meant to draw new users. BB10 will draw a lot of nerds wanting the latest and greatest. I’m going to be keeping a keen eye on week 1 and month 1 sales for the Z10.
GREAT post, Justin! I didn’t really get to watch the stream yesterday, but I caught up on the highlights afterwards. Your observations as a “phone nerd”? Totally legit
Agree with most of what you said! I am glad, though, that Blackberry is here to stay (for now).
the only think you missed during the presentation was the single worst scripting I’ve ever seen. There’s no more wooden a speaker than Thor.
where is your #getarealphone now!!!
The whole point of #GetARealPhone is to encourage strong buying decisions. If Blackberry has truly stepped their game up then more power to them. I’ll be happy to push their product as “real.”
Justin,
I have yet to really, really play with the either Z10 or Q10 in real life for a long enough period of time to make a judgement. You know me, I put phones through their paces and if anyone is a “power user” it is yours truly. However, I will say this about your comments re: hardware.
1. Camera – the number of megapixels after a certain point becomes irrelevant and it is more the sensor and the processing of the picture or something like that (I’m not a camera geek so I can’t speak their jargon). What I’m trying to say is the question really is what do pictures from the Z10 look like side by side vs other phones is the real question in terms of camera.
2. Processor/RAM – In terms of these it is only somewhat relevant what their speed is because the question is really how does the OS use the power? With QNX at its root BB10 should be a VERY robust system, be extremely lightweight, and be able to handle hardcore multitasking without requiring as much power. The argument I am making here is essentially the argument made in the “Straight guys respond to gay guys will marry your girlfriends” video: there’s a difference between being ripped and being the strong kind of ripped, the kind that wins bar fights. No rational person will give a crap if there’s less processing power if the OS manages in such a way that it runs smoother and faster than devices which have more cores or more ghz. At the end of the day, that’s all anyone should care about.
3. Battery – I gave up on cell phone batteries actually lasting me a full day a long, long time ago. From what I have heard the BlackBerry Z10 doesn’t exactly sip battery life like the BlackBerry devices of old but to be honest my Torch 9800 and Bold 9900 wouldn’t last me full days either. I kill phone batteries and have long made my peace with this situation. Go out and buy a portable battery if your phone usage is akin to mine or stop using so much social media and an LTE connection (ya, right) OR you can just go out and buy a dumb phone/feature phone (don’t make me laugh).
The camera has already been broken down by a few sites and it’s basically unanimous disappointment. The sensor has serious issues dealing with low light situations. It’s my feeling that Smartphone cameras should cap out at 12MP and then they should be refined to get as sharp an image as possible. Also, getting the best low light photo should be a top priority to Smartphone manufacturers at this point. If that can be nailed down, it would deal a crippling blow to P&S manufacturers, especially those selling entry level cameras.
My issue with processor/RAM isn’t about the OS. iOS has made it very clear you can cater the OS to work well on less than optimal specs. My issue lies in the fact that Blackberry made a strong push to show everyone they’re going to have a plethora of apps. On the higher end of the app scale, there’s no reason not to want the best processor/RAM. It’s like telling a gamer nerd not to build the latest and greatest comp to play the game he/she may want next year when they can just play what’s around this year.
Current reviews show the battery is underperforming even by standard Smartphone standards. From the 1 person I personally know that owns one and the reviews I’ve been reading, the battery life looks to be in the 6 – 8 hour range of regular use rather than the 8 – 10 hour range. I typically get 10 – 12 hours out of my iPhone4S on a standard day of regular use.
I think my impressions hold merit. Post days analysis at least shows my thoughts on Camera and battery were spot on. I’d concede they’ll likely get get the most juice out of the CPU/RAM but in terms of speed I”ve always felt faster is better so go for broke on that one (no pun intended).
Fair points but apps doesn’t necessarily mean games. I guess it also matters way less to me because I’m not a gamer and am even less interested in playing games on my phone.
I leave a response each time I appreciate a article on a website
I do have a couple of questions for you if it’s allright. Is it just me or does it look like a few of these remarks look like coming from brain dead folks?
And, if you are posting at additional sites, I would like to follow anything new you have to post. Would you make a list every one of your community sites like your twitter feed, Facebook page or linkedin profile?
or if I have something to add to the conversation.
It is a result of the sincerness displayed in the post I read.
And after this article Standout BB10 + Z10 Thoughts | Jmoney
Rambles. I was excited enough to leave a thought